The return of X-Men ’97 is almost here, and I’ll admit it: I’m both excited and slightly suspicious of my own excitement. How often does a revival manage to feel like a continuation rather than a nostalgic cash-in? In just a few weeks—on July 1—Marvel Television’s animated hit is set to come back for its second season on Disney+, picking up threads that started decades ago in X-Men: The Animated Series.
I recently found myself thinking about what’s really being revived when a show like this returns. Sure, it’s storylines and characters, but it’s also a very particular kind of audience relationship—one that has somehow survived the gaps between seasons, formats, and entire eras of fandom. At the Tribeca Film Festival, members of the cast and creative team talked about that relationship, and the stories they shared made the revival feel less like a product launch and more like a long-delayed reunion.
Back in 1992, nobody knew what they were sitting on
One detail that’s easy to forget now—when every franchise arrives pre-blessed by algorithmic certainty—is that the original series wasn’t guaranteed anything. Executive producer Julia Lewald described the early days with a kind of disbelief that still feels fresh: in 1992, they genuinely didn’t know if the show would find an audience, or if viewers would “find” the X-Men at all.
And then it happened: five seasons, a devoted fanbase, and a cultural footprint that never quite faded. Executive producer Eric Lewald put it in the plainest terms: you move on to other work assuming that chapter has closed. But the chapter didn’t close—it just kept being reread.
What struck me most was how he described the experience of attending conventions years later. People still show up dressed as versions of the characters tied specifically to their series—outfits preserved like time capsules from twenty or thirty years ago. And then comes the moment that, frankly, would melt even the most jaded producer: a parent and child, side by side, saying they watch it together. A 42-year-old dad and his 9-year-old daughter, bonding over the same show that once belonged to a different generation.
Julia Lewald’s reaction—basically, “How is this real?”—felt like the only honest response. “I watched it with my father. Now I watch it with my kid.” That’s not just fandom. That’s inheritance.
Theories, spoilers, and the joy of not knowing
If you’ve spent even five minutes online around a big genre release, you know the pattern: fans don’t simply watch stories anymore—they pre-watch them. They map them, predict them, argue them into existence. And according to Lenore Zann, the voice of Rogue (and one of the series’ most beloved performances), she’s having a great time watching the speculation swirl.
When people press her—online or at comic cons—about what’s coming next, she’s apparently perfected the gentle shutdown. Her message, delivered with a wink: it’s a story; let it unfold. No spoilers. No confirmation of the popular theories (yes, including the ones about Gambit’s fate and what form a return might take). Just a reminder that suspense is supposed to be part of the meal.
What makes this era different, Zann noted, is the immediacy. In the 1990s there was no social media feedback loop. No real-time reactions. No instant pile-ons or communal screaming into the same digital void. Now, fans respond episode by episode, moment by moment, and creators can actually see it happening as it happens.
She also made a point I think more viewers should keep in mind before they declare their predictions “obvious”: there are about 60 years of comics to pull from. In other words, certainty is a trap. The well is deep, and the show can draw from places you didn’t even know existed.
When Wolverine stops being a character and starts being a lifeline
The most emotional stories came from Cal Dodd, the voice of Wolverine—stories that made me reconsider how casually we talk about fictional characters “meaning a lot” to people. At conventions, Dodd said, he’ll sit at his table for eight or nine hours and somehow never gets tired of the interactions. Not because they’re easy, but because they’re often raw.
He described fans breaking down in tears. One young woman, around 19, wrote what he called a book—handwritten, thick, intensely personal—about why she loved Wolverine and the series, and how the character had saved her life multiple times. She handed him a copy and told him, essentially, to take it seriously: read it, and you might learn something about Wolverine.
Dodd’s response was honest and human—he doubted he’d learn something new about a character he’s inhabited for so long. And then he read it. And got to the middle. And found himself shaken.
What the fan had written about weren’t vague platitudes; they were specific scenes, specific lines, the kind of precise emotional memory you carry when something on screen has reached you at the exact moment you needed it. Dodd singled out an episode where Wolverine heads into the Arctic—an image of solitude so sharp you can feel the cold in your teeth. Wolverine pauses, takes in the air, senses Sabretooth, and then drops a line that landed like a stone for that viewer: “There’s no peace for me, not even here.”
For her, it mirrored how she felt growing up—being mocked, isolated, always on edge, never finding a place that felt safe. Dodd said it broke his heart. And he’s noticed, too, how many autistic fans connect deeply with that feeling of being perpetually out of sync with the world around them.
Then came another story—one he said was too big to fully tell in a single breath—about a person who credited Wolverine with saving their life, stopping them from jumping off a building. Years later, that person returned, not alone but with an 11-year-old daughter. And they said something that’s hard to shake: “I wouldn’t have this if it wasn’t for Wolverine.”
So yes, there’s plenty to discuss about animation styles, continuity, fan theories, and where the plot is headed. But hearing that, I can’t help asking you: when a show comes back, what exactly are you hoping it returns to? The lore? The vibe? Or that very specific feeling of being seen by a story that somehow found you first?
X-Men ’97 Season 2 premieres on Wednesday, July 1, exclusively on Disney+.
Comments